Perspectivesfrequal.com

The Painter: Review

After The Dog Stars, I was excited to read The Painter by Peter Heller. Having read the former, I was ready for a morally-ambiguous protagonist. What I didn't expect was a protagonist who is a murderer in modern day society. Even stranger, the more violence he becomes involved in, the more he finds professional success. Even law enforcement seem to live in a gray area in this novel, either not trying to hard or willing to look the other way if the dead are known miscreants.

As with The Dog Stars, the natural beauty of the southwest US is highlighted. The protagonist is an avid fisherman, and the streams are where he finds his peace, and also trouble.

I found the pacing and tension strong. The protagonist, who thinks his darkest days are behind him, finds himself drawn back in. The inability or unwillingness of law enforcement to more strenuously investigate the shady goings-on seemed surprising to me, though it fits with the overall "nothing is morally clear" theme. However, I never was as deeply drawn in as I was with The Dog Stars. In The Painter, you would expect the normal rules of society to function, but instead it seems like an alternate reality. For me, it was step too far for a novel set in the present day.

Rating:


Last modified on 7 Nov 2026 by AO

Copyright © 2026 Andrew Oliver